Doctor Who News River Song loves the Doctor - but not as much as we do.

Published on May 5th, 2014 | by Alex Skerratt

Doctor Who: In Need of a Woman’s Touch?

So many new writers, so few females! In the wake of the news that talented scribes Jamie Mathieson and Peter Harness will be penning some episodes for the upcoming Series 8, many people have lamented the lack of female input into the Whoniverse. Even the classic series was somewhat lacking a woman’s touch, especially when Attack of the Cybermen was revealed to have been written by Eric Saward and (allegedly) Ian Levine, (not Paula Moore, who didn’t even exist!)

Keen to buck the trend, the bods at What Culture have compiled a list of five female writers (“5 Women Who Need To Write For Doctor Who“) who they would like to see scribing for the good Doctor. Here’s what they have to say about them…

Una McCormack

“Although Una McCormack would be new to writing for television, the success of writers such as Paul Cornell, along with her own work on Doctor Who, show that she should not be dismissed so easily… In addition to her short stories, tie-in novels, and audio adventures she has also contributed essays to several Whoniverse reference books (one of which she co-edited), written for audiences which range from general fandom to academic scholars.”

Lucy Watkins

“Not only did she write four episodes of Merlin over a period of three years, but she held the pen behind Lancelot Du Lac, a somewhat pivotal episode… Writing for Doctor Who is obviously a big responsibility, but with high praise from the likes of SFX Magazine (and more importantly, the fans), this is something Watkins has proved she can handle.”

Jane Espenson

“…women made up a quarter of Torchwood’s writers, and penned over a third of the show’s episodes. That said however, Jane Espenson’s entries came as part of the show’s underwhelming US co-produced fourth season, Miracle Day. Not that this should be taken against Espenson personally, as she has also made contributions to beloved shows such as A Town Called Eureka, Deep Space Nine, Battlestar Galactica, and, of course, Buffy the Vampire Slayer.”

Jessica Hynes

“…Jessica Hynes joined Doctor Who’s (extended) family as an actress rather than a writer, and is best known to Whovians for portraying Joan Redfern in the highly acclaimed two-parter Human Nature / The Family of Blood. That said however, describing her only as an actress would be doing Hynes a massive discredit. Hynes initially proved her writing credentials when she co-wrote the cult sitcom Spaced… with Simon Pegg.  More recently she also penned the BBC4 comedy Up the Women, a sitcom set during the women’s suffragette movement in 1910.”

Catherine Tregenna

“As mentioned before, Torchwood was more than happy for women to write episodes alongside the men. Of these, Out of Time, and Captain Jack Harkness are in contention to be among the best of the whole series. Both were written by Catherine Tregenna… [She] has proved herself more than capable of handling characters audiences know and love… and with a nomination for such a prestigious sci-fi award [the Hugo], it is quite simply mind-boggling as to why she hasn’t written for the show already, especially during Russell T Davies’ tenure as executive producer.”

I certainly couldn’t argue with any of these nominations, and I must concur that Catherine Tregenna wrote some of my favourite episodes of Torchwood. But I would also like to throw the name Tanith Lee (alias Esther Garber) into the ring. She is an award-winning writer of over 90 novels and 300 short stories, including two sensational episodes of Blake’s 7 back in the 1980s. Also, how about letting Kay Mellor (The Chase, The Syndicate) loose in the TARDIS for a while…?

Anyway, keep the suggestions coming, Kasterborites! Who would you like to write for the series?


Tags: , , , , , ,

About the Author


likes William Hartnell, whisky, being creative, debating canonicity, The Gunfighters, The Keys of Marinus and City of Death. He has a strong dislike of cold quiche, corporate PowerPoint presentations and lanyards, but loves terrible puns. He's currently employed by a mute teddy bear with black ears.

13 Responses to Doctor Who: In Need of a Woman’s Touch?

  1. avatar Rick says:

    What about getting Rona Munro back? Survival was a great story, and she’s since gone on to become a respected playwright. So she’d be a source of talent and prestige

    • avatar iankiddy says:

      Exactly… so why would she want to write for a show as narrow and restrictive as New Who? Cartmel gave her free reign to write whatever story she wanted, in whatever style she wanted. I can’t imagine any writer on New Who being given that sort of freedom these days.

  2. avatar jon says:

    personally i’d like them to get the writer of the crimson field

  3. avatar Ian Scales says:

    What about Debbie Moon, showrunner and lead writer for Wolfblood, a children’s tv series that adults adore! She has long said she would love to write for Who. Guess it’s a boys’ club once again though now.

  4. avatar Tony Sobol says:

    As well as Debbie Moon, I’d include Being Human’s Sarah Dollard and film writer Jane Goldman (X-Men: First Class) as some very obvious choices.

  5. avatar Paul says:

    I’d like to nominate the team behind the show ITV Scott and Bailey. The majority of the episodes are written by Sally Wainwright but a few have been written by Amelia Bullmore. The show is a solid well written show that has strong female leads, but that isn’t the be all and end all of the thing. In the grand scheme of things I don’t see why there should be a Science Fiction background in there if the talent is evident.

  6. avatar rickjlundeen says:

    Just give me good writing, period. I don’t care about their race or sex.

    • avatar Joyce says:

      Yes indeed. It just needs to be good.

  7. avatar yvonne says:

    My choices: Jeannine Renshaw, Alison Schapker, Monica Breen, Nora Kay Foster, Thania St. John, Karen Walton, Raelle Tucker, and Marti Noxin.

  8. avatar Chad says:

    I absolutely agree with Jane Espenson. I would also include fellow Buffy alum Marti Noxon who helped produce and write the first season of Mad Men.

  9. avatar alex says:

    Tanith Lee should be commissioned to write an episode of doctor who. She would be mad brilliant at it

  10. avatar Philip Bates says:

    I’d rather not Espenson – her Torchwood eps weren’t for me (though Categories of Life was good).

    Otherwise, as long as the story is good, it doesn’t matter what gender the writer is. Or the director. Or producer, or designer, or caterer.

    … Although Sally Wainwright is fantastic. Get her on Who, Mr. Moffat.

  11. I would suggest Alice Nutter who has written for radio, the stage and television. She is unahamedly on the left and would be a writer in the vein of Malcolm Hulke, for instance or Robert sloman

Please be aware that all comments are subject to adherence to our comments policy.
Back to Top ↑