Doctor Who News no image

Published on October 31st, 2010 | by Meredith Burdett

Find and Replace

Each month a new story for The Companion Chronicles is released and each month they continue to amaze the listener with their originality and compact story telling. Find and Replace does this with ease but also manages to tug at the heart strings while doing so.

It’s a busy month for Jo Grant as not only has she met Sarah Jane Smith and the Eleventh Doctor on screen in The Sarah Jane Adventures but according to this story, she’s also popped back in time for a quick reunion with the Third Doctor as well!

Let me explain. In Find and Replace, Jo is out in London Christmas shopping. She’s happy and bubbly as always and is enjoying her existence to its fullest. That is until she gets stuck in a lift with a creature called Huxley from Verbatim Six. Huxely is a narrator who’s come to let Jo relive the best time of her life, when she was travelling with the space/time adventuress known as… Iris Wildthyme.

And that’s where the mystery starts to unfold for the listener as we wonder how exactly this Huxley (Alex Lowe) character has got his information so wrong. Iris first emerged in the BBC Doctor Who books in the 1990’s as a sort of rougher and less distinguished River Song. Brass, loud and slightly mad, she was quite the problem maker for the Doctors various incarnations (she’s met several). Big Finish later re-established her character via the audio format where she’s been played for a number of years by Katy Manning.

With Find and Replace, Katy not only reprises her role as Jo Grant but also as Iris. She carries the conversations between the two characters off so well that at times it’s hard to imagine that it’s one tiny little actress doing all this splendid work.

As the story moves forward, Jo and Iris end up back at UNIT HQ for quite the reunion. Sergeant Benton is encountered in all his wide eyed innocence as Jo and Iris react to him in quite different ways. Then it’s on to Jo’s reunion with the Third Doctor, where the entire plot is explained. But it’s not really that relevant as what you end up listening to is possibly one of the most moving conversations that Big Finish has ever produced. The Doctor and Jo’s delight to see each other is hampered by, what Jo feels, has been a betrayal of her trust. This dialogue then flows nicely onto a tearful Jo telling the Doctor, her Doctor, that life is never quite the same once he’s gone and how the memories of their times together keep her moving forward. It’s a wonderful monologue played out with a painful sincerity by Manning. Not only has she caught that mannerisms of Jon Pertwee’s portrayal of the Doctor exactly right, you can really feel the emotion rising in her voice as she clearly talks to her dearly departed friend, not only in the play but in real life as well.

Elegant and passionate with a touch of light heartedness and nostalgia at some points, Find and Replace will make you remember why you love Doctor Who.

Find and Replace is by Paul Magrs and available on CD and MP3 from www.bigfinish.com!

Enhanced by Zemanta

email

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,


About the Author

What happens when an eight year old kid watches the 1993 repeat run of Planet of the Daleks? He pretty much ends up here writing about the show that grabbed hold of him and never let go!




One Response to Find and Replace

  1. Lazarus77 says:

    I’d never compared Iris to River before but I suppose the romantic overtures are similar (not to mention the meeting each other out of order)…

    I’d always seen River as Berniece Summerfield if Benny had been with more than one Doctor or had met him out of order.

    But your comparison makes more sense.

Please be aware that all comments are subject to adherence to our comments policy.
Back to Top ↑