News no image

Published on May 27th, 2010 | by Joe Siegler

4

The Edge of Destruction Review

A Doctor Who adventure that takes place in the TARDIS? The travellers unsure what is going on? No, it’s not Amy’s Choice – it’s The Edge of Destruction, from 1964…

Doctor Who - The Edge of Destruction

When I was a little kid, I loved the original Star Trek (I was 1 when it started). My favorite stories were ones that showed other parts of the ship, and particularly ones treat took place completely inside the ship. Modern TV calls something like that a “bottle show”; a story that saves money. But for me as a kid, I just wanted to see other bits of the Enterprise. I loved shows like that. So when I got into Doctor Who, I scanned the back catalogue of episodes, and found a distinct lack of that kind of story. One episode in Tom Baker’s era was like this (Episode 6 of Invasion of Time), and just one full story, an old William Hartnell story. That was it. So that was a bit disappointing. But when Hartnell’s stories started airing in the US around 1986 or so, I looked forward to The Edge of Destruction for this reason – it was an “all on the ship” show, which lends to one of this story’s names, Inside the Spaceship (although I prefer the more common The Edge of Destruction).

The Doctor and Barbara in Doctor Who - The Edge of DestructionThis story was the third story overall, following directly from the wildly successful original Dalek story. It was designed to explore the characters interactions with each other. The Doctor at this point was a rather cantankerous fellow, even for the First Doctor. It starts off innocently enough with the travelers around the TARDIS console, and for some reason unknown, at the time, they’re knocked unconscious and lay on the floor of the TARDIS, which was kind of an odd start to the episode. As they start to come around, they obviously wonder what happened to them to be knocked unconscious. On top of that, they don’t seem to recognize their current situation, or all of each other. The Doctor is the worst off, with his head being cut in the fall and spending a decent percentage of time of the episode unconscious. Something that seems to happen a lot to Hartnell as his time in the role went on.

The early part of this episode seems to feature Barbara a lot in a mothering role to the other characters. I point this out, as it seemed well, I don’t know. I start to say weird, and then it isn’t, and I start to say “in character”, and it isn’t either. Not entirely sure how I feel about that.

As they come around, strange things start to happen. Susan goes to get a glass of water from some sort of food/drink machine, and is told the machine is empty when it was not. The doors of the TARDIS open and close on their own when people walk towards them. Another was the fault locator saying every single thing was wrong with the TARDIS simultaneously. All of these things are later on shown to be clues towards the final resolution of the story. One of the more notorious bits was Susan trying to attack Ian with a pair of scissors, which she freaks out over and stabs the bed a ton of times. If you watch the extras on the DVD for this story, Verity Lambert admits the scissor stab bits were something that were probably better left out. This goes on until the characters all suspect each other of sabotaging the ship, or being under alien control or just outright mutiny. Even up until the point where the Doctor threatens to put Ian & Barbara off the ship. At which point Barbara loses it, and yells at the Doctor, calling him a “stupid old man”. Other strangeness was Ian trying to strangle the Doctor. This all carries on for awhile – pretty much through most of Episode 2 as well. The crew mistrusts, threatens, and says a bunch of rude things to each other.

William Hartnell starred in Doctor Who 1963-1966One of the better moments in this story is a dialogue by Hartnell towards the end of part two. Hartnell is known for his frequent muffing of his lines. Due to the production values of the time, a lot of these are left in. However, there’s a couple minute speech by the Doctor where he pulls it off well, and is one of the better moments of the Hartnell era in terms of his own acting. Shortly after said speech, the overall plot is resolved, and everything is made well again. I won’t divulge exactly what it was, but look out for some handwritten words on the TARDIS console, which were allegedly there to help Hartnell locate specific spots on the console during filming.

Parts of this story have been used in other stories further down the line – way down the line in the series. The biggest one of which is that the TARDIS itself is seemingly alive – or at least can think for itself. It is eventually revealed that the ship itself was the cause of all the strange happenings to try and hint the crew as to the real reason behind all the strange happenings. This was used later on many times in the show’s future. A specific TARDIS “feature” from this story was that the power of the TARDIS is under the console, something that was used later on in Eccleston’s run a few times. One of these times was in Boom Town where the TARDIS itself manipulates time to turn Margaret into a Slitheen egg. You could also extrapolate this into perhaps the TARDIS turning back time and reviving Grace & Chang Lee from death in the Eighth Doctor movie. There’s also the time in Eccleston’s final episode where Rose looks into the TARDIS console and get the power of time and space inside her, too. The Confidential episode for that story references “The Edge of Destruction” and this concept too as inspirations for these specific plot points.

Doctor Who - The Parting of the Ways

There’s also some strange contradictions to other established bits of Who lore in this story, however, since it’s just the third overall, and the 12th & 13th overall episodes, that can be forgiven, I suppose. Ian mentions “his heart”, implying that he has just one. I forget where exactly it was established for sure that the Doctor had two hearts – I think it was Pertwee’s first story. Susan also says “the ship can’t crash, it’s impossible”. This has been shown to be false, as it has crashed a few times over the years, most recently in Matt Smith’s debut The Eleventh Hour. This story is also one of only two times that I’m aware of we see a bed in the TARDIS console room. The other time was when Pertwee was knocked unconscious at the end of Frontier in Space going into Planet of the Daleks. Oddly enough, both beds come out of walls – “oooh, so modern looking!” :)

Doctor Who - The Edge of Destruction and Frontier in Space

As I said earlier, this story served to galvanize the TARDIS crew as friends. They were more companions by situation up until this point. After the problems were resolved, there’s a rather nice scene or two at the end where the Doctor makes up with Barbara, and there’s some fun with throwing snowballs and whatnot, which is a direct lead-in to the next story, Marco Polo.

In all, this story is a somewhat overlooked story from what I can gather, but it was important in establishing character relationships, and somewhat unintentionally (I gather) responsible for putting forth a few show concepts that are still in use now in 2010. When I reach for an early series DVD or whatnot, this isn’t the first one chosen, but there are some great points here to see. Give The Edge of Destruction (or Inside the Spaceship, or whatever you want to call it) a shot. You might enjoy this long ago small scale bottle story as much as I did.

William Hartnell and Jacqueline Hill in Doctor Who - The Edge of Destruction

Overall Story Information:

Story Title: The Edge of Destruction (aka Inside the Spaceship & Beyond the Sun)
Production Code: C
Writer: David Whitaker
Script Editor: David Whitaker
Length: 2 episodes

William Hartnell – The Doctor
Carole Ann Ford – Susan Foreman
Jacqueline Hill – Barbara Wright
William Russell – Ian Chesterton

Specific Episode Information:

Episode 1: “The Edge of Destruction”

Broadcast Date: Feb 8, 1964
Director: Richard Martin

Episode 2: “The Edge of Destruction”

Broadcast Date: Feb 15, 1964
Director: Frank Cox

External Links of Note for the Edge of Destruction:

Ordering this Story:

The Edge of Destruction was released as part of a box set entitled “The Beginning”, which also includes An Unearthly Child, The Daleks, and a reconstruction of Marco Polo. You can buy this box set online at the following links:

Video:

NOTE: The BBC has legally allowed the two episodes of this story to be placed on Youtube for full and free viewing. The links to the two episodes are below:

email

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,


About the Author

avatar




4 Responses to The Edge of Destruction Review

  1. avatar Patrick Riley says:

    Thanks for this! One of my favorite classic stories!

  2. avatar Rick714 says:

    Indeed! Well done. “The Beginning” box set is a great primer for all Who fans and amongst the many treats with Edge of Destruction and the Daleks, many new fans will appreciate the very first episode of An Unearthly child as it has some similar elements to “Rose”, most importantly, seeing the Doctor and the Tardis for the first time through the eyes of companions, Ian and Barbara. Long weekend coming up…might be time to watch these three adventures again!

  3. avatar Shall We Destroy says:

    The assertion that the Doctor’s speech “is one of the better moments of the Hartnell era in terms of his own acting” is quite irritating.

    Even knowing that Hartnell’s infamous ‘Billy-fluffs’ were down to illness and the way TV was produced in the sixties, it’s unsurprising that they’d sway modern audiences’ attitudes toward the First Doctor. However, the implication that his acting was somehow under par in general seems short-sighted.

    The effectiveness of all the Doctors is clearly going to be influenced by their era at large, but you only have to watch, say, The Crusade, or The Aztecs, An Unearthly Child, etc etc, to see what an impressive actor (and effective Doctor) William Hartnell was.

    Neil
    http://shallwedestroy.blogspot.com/

  4. Pingback: Don't Overlook The Hartnell Era Of Doctor Who | Kasterborous Doctor Who News

Tell us what you think!

Back to Top ↑