Published on January 29th, 2008 | by Christian Cawley
Surveillance State of Decay
Under the skin tracking devices are here – and at the moment it appears that they are here to stay, regardless of our fears. And they’ve shown up in the Whoniverse… is Torchwood being used to condition us?
One of the of the countryâ€™s highest ranked policemen, Chief Constable Ken Jones, has suggested a sci fi fix for keeping sex offenders under surveillance. Is embedding tracking devices embedded under their skin morally right though?
The principle of it was seen only last week in the Dr Who spin-off Torchwood when a character had one put under her skin to gather information and keep track of her. Film buffs will remember The Manchurian Candidate in which characters are controlled by “bugs” implanted in the neck.
Although the above reference to Torchwood is only a very loose interpretation, the technology exists now. However as with the various cases of high-level data loss by government departments, we need to ask ourselves: are we mature enough as a society to handle the solutions afforded to us by technology?
The answer can only be “no”. Sex offenders – however abhorrent – have rights that cannot be be denied, and on of those is their freedom of movement when living in society.
We should all be horrified at the suggestion of tracking humans with intravenous implants. If we go back to the matter of sex offenders – chemical castration can be used to negate their threat. So why isn’t this being offered as a legitimate solution?
Chemical castration is by no means more attractive to anyone that believes in human rights – however it is one that doesn’t open the doors to a big brother dominion over the populace.